What running a fansite at 13 taught me about visual identity, community and SEO
I built my first celebrity fansite at 13, on fan-club.it. There was no budget and no analytics, but there was a lot of design work: I kept redesigning layouts and visuals, often around a theme, and made my own banners for affiliations with other fan clubs. It turned out to be the best marketing school I could have had. Here are the seven lessons that still apply to brands today.
1. The look is the first thing people judge
On fan-club.it a large part of my work was graphics: headers, backgrounds, buttons, the whole layout, plus custom banners for the site. Before anyone read a line, visitors judged the site by how it looked, and a well-kept fansite earned trust on the spot.
That is brand identity in miniature. For a brand today it works the same way: the visual system (colours, type, image style, layout) is the first promise you make, and every channel either keeps it or breaks it.
2. Change the visual with the story, keep the core
I changed layout and visuals often, and often around a theme: a new era, an event, a release. Each new look told visitors that something was happening and gave them a reason to come back.
It was also my first lesson in systems. The site always stayed recognisable (structure, navigation, tone) while the theme rotated. That is exactly how seasonal and campaign creative should work for a brand: a stable core, a flexible skin.
3. Fans come back for a rhythm, not for a pitch
A fansite lived or died on one question: is there something new today? The news section was the heartbeat: updates, photos, a translated interview, a fixed link. People came back because the site was reliably alive, and a new look gave them one more thing to look forward to.
That is a content calendar, long before the term was fashionable. A steady rhythm your audience can predict beats an occasional big campaign. Pick a cadence you can keep for a year, then protect it.
4. Learn the exact words people use
You quickly learn what people type into a search box: a name, a song, a date, “wallpaper”, “gallery”, “lyrics”. Each of those is an intent, and each deserved its own page with a clear title, a short description and links to related pages.
I taught myself HTML and CSS to build the layouts, and SEO came as a side effect of wanting to be found. It is the same method I use now: start from the words the audience really uses (not the brand’s internal vocabulary), give each intent a page and connect them with sensible internal links.
5. Twinnings were collab posts, long before Instagram
I designed my own banners so that other fan sites could display them. That is how affiliations and “twinnings” with other fan clubs worked: you showed each other’s banners, linked to each other and sent each other visitors who already shared the same interest.
Today the closest thing is an Instagram Collab post or Reel: one piece of content, published jointly, that appears on both profiles and reaches both audiences. The logic is identical. A shared audience, something good-looking made to be shown on both sides, and a clear agreement on who posts what and when.
What I would carry over: choose partners whose followers really overlap with yours, make the content together instead of just tagging each other, and keep the partnership going over time. One collab is a mention, a series of them is a relationship.
6. Community is built in the open
The guestbook taught me that a community needs three things: a place to speak, someone who answers, and clear rules. People wrote because they felt seen, and the tone of the replies set the tone of the whole space.
On social media this becomes comments, DMs, user-generated content and moderation. For a brand it means deciding who answers, in which voice and how fast, before the first angry or enthusiastic comment arrives.
7. Own the relationship, rent the platform
Platforms change, algorithms change and spaces where communities lived have a way of disappearing. The audience you can reach directly, through your own site and an email list, is the one you keep.
That is why I treat newsletters as a core channel, not an afterthought, and why I started Mixtape. A good newsletter gives the people who follow you a regular appointment that lands in their inbox, with no algorithm deciding whether they see it.
From seven lessons to one checklist: questions to ask before any brand project
These seven lessons became the questions I now ask at the start of every brand project. Use them as a quick checklist, whatever the size of the brand.
- What does the brand look like at first glance? Check that every channel keeps the same visual promise.
- What is the stable core, and what can change? Define the system first, then the seasonal themes.
- Which partners share your audience? Plan a series of joint posts or Reels, not a one-off tag.
- Who is already talking about you? Find the community first, then the strategy.
- What do people actually name it? Use the names they use for your product or service in titles, captions and keywords.
- Can you keep the rhythm? Choose a cadence that survives a busy month.
- Which channel do you own? Build the email list before you need it.
The takeaway: same work, new tools
The tools have changed, from hand-built layouts and banners to Reels, from guestbooks to Discord and from twinnings to Instagram collabs, but the work is the same: a recognisable look that evolves with the story, useful and consistent content, the community’s own language and a direct line to the people who care. I learned that at 13, and it still shapes how I plan campaigns.
Want a brand that people actually come back to?
I help brands build a recognisable visual identity and the channels they own, from SEO and content to email and paid media. Based in Milan, working worldwide. Remote-first, with brands in the UK, EU, US and Australia.
Get in touch